Last updated: 17 November 2026
For the past year our Audi RS6 C8 Avant has been the family car, and it has been close to perfect at it. Then our new RS5 B10 Avant arrived. We bought the RS6 knowing the RS5 was coming and that the older car would be a stop-gap, yet two months later both were still on the drive. As a business we can't justify keeping two fast Audi estates, so one had to go.
To decide, we put them side by side over four rounds: what they cost, how they look, what they are like to live with and how they drive. This guide follows those rounds and says plainly who each car suits, including why the one we kept may not be the right answer for you.
In the film, Jack takes both cars through the four rounds, scores each one, then drives them back to back before choosing which one stays.
Our two cars, and what's on each
Neither car is standard, and that matters when you read our opinions, especially on ride and looks.
The RS5 B10 is a plug-in hybrid with a twin-turbo V6, an electric motor and quattro. Ours is lowered on H&R height-adjustable springs set to their lowest point, and it sits on pre-production 22in TREVORA PR-1 forged wheels with 25-profile tyres and no spacers. It also runs a prototype Milltek exhaust, which Jack describes in the film as stupidly loud. There is no body kit on it yet. The full story of the springs and wheels is in our RS5 B10 lowering springs guide.
The RS6 C8 is the twin-turbo V8 car. The changes you can see on ours are a FORM Industries FI-1 pre-preg carbon kit, made up of a front splitter, front bumper covers, side skirts, a rear diffuser and a rear spoiler, and a set of HRE FF21 flow-form wheels. The HREs went on using the car's original tyres, moved straight across, which kept the change simple. If you want to know how the car started out with us, we covered the day we collected it.

Price: which makes more sense to buy and run?
This round ended in a tie, because the answer depends almost entirely on how you buy.
Our RS6 was bought used. It had already taken a good share of its depreciation, and its value has held up well since. For a car with this much ability, a good used RS6 is strong value.
The RS5 is a new car, it cost us more than the RS6 did, and we expect it to lose value faster over its first few years. Where it pulls back is tax. As a plug-in hybrid it sits in a far lower company car tax band than the V8 RS6, so if the car is bought through a business, the monthly Benefit in Kind bill is a fraction of the RS6's. That alone can cover much of the gap in purchase price. How much it saves you depends on your own circumstances, so it is worth asking your accountant before you choose.
Fuel points the same way. The V8 wants super unleaded and it is thirsty, while the RS5 can cover a lot of short journeys on electricity if you can charge at home.
Our view: a cash buyer is probably better off with the RS6, and someone buying on finance or through a business is probably better off with the RS5.
Looks: does the RS5 make the RS6 look dated?
A little, yes, and the RS5 won this round.
The B10 is aggressive at the front and properly wide at the rear. Audi fitted the RS5 with its own wider doors to make room for the arches, and the car looks like no expense was spared on the design. Lowered on the TREVORA wheels, it is the car we find ourselves stopping to look at.

It isn't perfect. The radar panel in the front is large and hard to ignore, when other brands in the same group hide those sensors behind the badge. The badge itself looks small on such a big face. The door handles are gloss black, and we think body colour would have been neater. The exhaust tips now sit closer to the centre of the bumper, which divides opinion. We are fairly neutral on them. It is also worth looking at the Saloon before you order. We were set on the Avant, then saw a Saloon in the metal and liked it just as much.

The RS6 is angular and muscular, and in a dark colour it can go almost unnoticed. That restraint is why it has aged so well. Next to the RS5, though, it is starting to look its age. It will never look bad, because Audi kept the design simple, but on our car the FORM Industries carbon does a lot of the work of keeping it modern.

The rear is still the RS6's best angle. Following one on the road, it looks as though it is bursting out of its own bodywork, and the carbon diffuser makes the most of that.

Inside and every day: where the RS6 still wins
The RS6 has the better cabin, and it wasn't a close call.
It feels like a quality product. Everything is well put together, the screens are sharp and clear and show only what you need, and the touch panels use haptic feedback, so pressing one feels like pressing a real button. Years after launch, it still feels modern.

The RS5 has more technology, possibly too much. The central screen shows a lot more at once, there is a third screen on top, and the menus are confusing. Even after a good number of miles, we still struggle to find things, so we leave the screens on the map. In the film, Jack calls that driver display a massive step back from the RS6, both in how it looks and in the information it gives you.
The materials are a notch below the RS6, which is fair given the RS5 sits a class below it. Most of what you touch feels good for the money, and better than some rivals, but there are a few harder plastics lower down.

For space, both cars have plenty of room in the back. The RS5's boot floor sits slightly higher, and, as Jack points out in the film, his dog has noticeably less room than she does in the RS6. Day to day, unless you use your estate as a van, you would be hard pressed to tell the difference.
There is one point in the RS5's favour that belongs here as much as anywhere. Its hybrid drivetrain arguably makes it the better daily car. On cabin and space alone, though, this round goes to the RS6.
How do the RS5 B10 and RS6 C8 drive?
Neither car is meant to be a sharp-edged driver's car, and both should be judged as quick, comfortable estates you can use every day.
The RS6 C8
It is smooth and refined enough that you can forget the V8 is there, until you put your foot down and it pulls with enormous force. It also sounds wonderful, and the character of that engine is the thing we would miss most. The suspension is noticeably softer than our RS5's, and the car is tuned for comfort, so it can feel a little wafty at times. For a car this big, it is very fast, and it doesn't feel as heavy as it is.
The RS5 B10
It sounds good from the moment you start it, with a V6 note that Jack likens in the film to a Nissan GT-R. The gearbox is the weak spot. It can hesitate on upshifts and sometimes seems unsure which gear it wants on the way down, which leaves you feeling slightly out of step with the car. It isn't a car you buy for its handling, and it wouldn't match an M3 for outright pace or engagement, as our RS5 versus M3 xDrive comparison covers. What surprised us is how well it hides its weight, arguably better than the RS6.
The hybrid system is what makes it work as a daily car. With home charging, we can drive it on battery alone on most days, silently, then have the loud exhaust and the V6 when we want them.
Our RS5's firm ride is our own doing
Back to back, the RS6 rides better. That is mostly down to how we have set up our RS5: the springs are at their lowest setting, and the car is on 22in wheels with 25-profile tyres. You don't need to go that low. Raising the ride height a little and fitting a tyre with a taller sidewall would bring much of the comfort back. If you are choosing springs for a B10, the fixed H&R springs give a more moderate drop, and the height-adjustable kit lets you settle on the height that suits your roads. Our spring guide compares the two.
Which one we kept, and why
The RS5 B10 stays.
The V8 RS6 is a remarkable car that can do almost everything, and there is a reason it earned the family supercar label. But it has become hard to justify running. The RS5 does nearly everything the RS6 does, and its hybrid drivetrain suits how we use it. As Jack explains in the film, he can leave for the gym before sunrise on electric power without waking the neighbours, charge at home, and still have a loud exhaust for the drive back. Add the looks, and for us the RS5 is the better all-round package. It doesn't sound as good as the V8, and it is heavy, but it drives well and it is the car we would rather live with.
It also doesn't have a body kit yet, so our RS5 is not finished.
| Round | Winner | What decided it |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Tie | The used RS6 holds its value; the RS5 costs far less in company car tax |
| Looks | RS5 B10 | A fresher, wider design, despite a few details we would change |
| Inside and every day | RS6 C8 | Better build quality, clearer screens and a little more boot space |
| Driving and verdict | RS5 B10 | The RS6 is faster and softer, but hybrid running and the overall package won it |

Should you buy the RS5 B10 or the RS6 C8?
Our choice was personal, so here is how we would decide if we were in your position.
Buy the RS6 C8 if
You are buying with cash and want a car that has already done most of its depreciating. You want a V8 while you still can, and a softer ride. You value a cabin that is easy to use and well built, and the most boot space. You also want the widest choice of proven parts, from carbon kits to wheels.
Buy the RS5 B10 if
You are buying through a business or on finance, where the tax difference counts for a lot. You can charge at home and do enough short trips to run on electricity most of the time. You want the newer design, and you are happy that parts support is still growing, as it always is for a new model.
If you are an RS6 owner wondering whether to change, take a long test drive in the RS5 first, and spend time with the screens and the gearbox as well as the looks. If they don't bother you, the hybrid running is the reason to change.
Modifying each one: where to start
On the RS5 B10, start with the stance. The factory ride height leaves a clear gap above the tyres, and H&R springs close it. Choose the fixed kit for a set drop or the height-adjustable kit if you want to pick your own height. After that, wheels. Ours are pre-production TREVORA PR-1 forged wheels, and if you are keeping the factory wheels, our RS5 wheel spacer guide shows what each spacer size does. Everything we list for the car is in our RS5 B10 Avant and RS5 B10 Saloon collections.
On the RS6 C8, the FORM Industries FI-1 kit is what gives our car its sharper look. You don't have to fit all of it at once. The front splitter, front bumper covers, side skirts, rear diffuser and rear spoiler are each sold separately, so you can build it in stages. The HRE FF21 is a flow-form wheel that freshens the car without changing its character. For more ideas, see our top five modifications for the RS6 C8 or the full RS6 C8 collection.

AUTOID is the authorised UK exclusive distributor for TREVORA, FORM Industries and HRE, and an authorised dealer for H&R. We fit parts for both cars at our workshop in Chelmsford, and everything we sell comes with a minimum six-month guarantee from us. Call us on 020 3780 0770 to talk through your car.

0 commentaire